I’m pretty sure Windows 8 remembers the last UI used. Every time I bring my PC back from sleep it’s on the desktop UI. This means instead of Metro not compromising and providing me with a classic desktop experience, my desktop has a full-screen Start menu. And, by the way, that’s what I’m calling Metro from now on. Full-screen Start.
Compare that to say, OS X, which actually provides compromise. It lets apps run full screen and windowed, whereas, ironically, Windows doesn’t. I get full screen or windowed. No compromise.
Microsoft is in the midst of what is likely the most public battle with cognitive dissonance in tech history. It believes that users want both a classic UI with one set of controls, logics and experiences simultaneously with another UI with its own set of controls, logics and experiences that are subtly entwined, utterly dependent upon each other, yet breathtakingly unaware that either exist.


